The bride must not be married, she must attain the permission of her wali if she has never been married before, she must be muslim or belong to ahl alkitab people of the book, she should be chaste, must not be a known adulterer, and she can only independently do this if. Dec 18, 2010 muta marriage is valid type of marriage in shia jurisprudence. Masturbation is haram prohibited, however if there is a medical necessity for a mukallaf dutybound muslim to perform that and the ejaculation could not be achieved through lawful means then other means are permissible. Alkafi is the most reliable of the four shia books of hadith. Shias would you practice temporary marriage yahoo answers. Aug 21, 2015 august 21, 2015 in mutah, shia sunni, sunni scholars tags. Mutah discussed, comments by salman sunniforum and shayk faraz rabbani sunnipath then as to those by whom you take pleasure give them their appointed dowers 6. More shia hadith on mutah mutah is not only allowed in the shia religion, but it is actually actively encouraged. Permanent marriage muta marriage or temporary marriage a shia of the male sex may contract a muta marriage with a woman professing the muslim, christian or jewish religion, or even with a woman who is a fireworshiper.
The ulama, both sunni and shii, agree that muta was permitted at the beginning of islam. Oct 23, 2018 mutah is an old islamic practice for the men who used to travel long distances and needed someone to please with. Shia books proving mutha is harramforbidden prohibition of mutah in shia text. In the book of mustadrakalwasa il shia authentic hadith book vol. As for the shia trying to prove that mutah is halal even in sunni fiqh, we could just as easily prohibit mutah in the shia fiqh by playing around with their hadith. The official website of the office of his eminence alsayyid. Shia books of hadith ahaadith, narrations welcome to shia. It is sad that the shia elders use false rhetoric to demand that their followers reject logic and morality, to instead blindly accept the idea that prostitution is part of islam. After a brief overview of books of tafsir in part i, let us now look at some of the sunni collections of traditions. It is narrated in both bukari and muslim, that ali said. Shia library a great collection of books from shia sect. In shia islam there are two kinds of halal marriage, mutah temporary and nikah permanent and each has its own conditions, benefits and limitations.
Mutah an alternative shia perspective book references. Another shia muhaqiq muhammad ibn hassan al hurr al amili has reported this narration in his book, wasail al shia ila tahsil masail al shariah volume 7 page 441. Misyar can be a temporary arrangement, but unlike the muta marriage, which ends on the expiration date of the contract, the misyar has no certain date. Most shia of today have a hard time selfjustifying the concept of mutah. Dec 3, 2016 free download or read online muta ki haqeeqat the reality of muta, a beautiful islamic book about muta and islam by shaykh usman bin mohammad al khamis. The word khalifa by definition means to follow and the traditional thinking about the rightly guided khalifas is their rigid adherence to the sunnah of the prophet and the book of god in all matters. There are more forensics to prove that mutah was not considered legitimate by the ahlul baith. It refers to the shia belief in temporary marriage in which a man pays a woman and it becomes permissible for the man to have sexual relations with her for a fixed period of time. We have designed this app especially for muslims all over the world who are fond of. Why would umar ra prohibit this marriage if it was already known that mutah is haram. Imam ahmad bin hanbal is one of the greatest scholars of ahlusunnah, not only in hadeeth, but also in fiqh. In the shia context, mutah refers to a temporary marriage. Please practice handwashing and social distancing, and check out our resources for adapting to these times. Ingenuously the arguments about mutah have always been turned in to a sunni versus shia issue when the real issue is how we have turned shia islam in to a capricious religion where the.
Mutah is an old islamic practice for the men who used to travel long distances and needed someone to please with. However, since shias believe that allah swt cannot do wrong and his actions are aslah most beneficial, everything has a purpose. The shia mujtahidin and the lovers of mutah are extremely distressed with this narration present in their own books. The holy prophet allowed us tomarry a woman for a limited period in exchange for. Misyar marriage is defined as an official marital relationship between a man and a woman who do not live together, and where the husband is not financially responsible for a misyar wife. Mutah has been explicitly categorized as haram by the sunnis. The very act of indulging in a temporary marriage has triggered a multitude of emotional reactions from muslims and nonmuslims alike. Mutah is also called pleasure marriage and seems very attractive to those who believe in sexual pleasure. In fact, it is a point which causes many of them to doubt their faith, and rightfully so.
The author states that ali lied for the purposes of taqiya. This website contains a well sorted collection of shia books you can find hundreds of books on shia community. Mutta marriage or temporary marriage contract in shia islam. However, it is still practiced in several parts of the shia dominant regions of the world. Many of the hadith that the shia bring up that use the word mutah are actually referring to mutah alhajj, and have nothing to do with mutah alnisa. Islamic shia books which provide shia beliefs narrative in different languages such as. Mar 30, 2016 boko haram insurgents had changed tactics and targeted churches in an onslaught of bombings on christmas day. Alahkam alkhamsah wajib, haram, mustahab, makru and mubah.
Mut ah means to marry a lady for a prescribed period of time, and this is forbidden and haraam according to all the four madhabs. Taijani samavi it means the mutah marirage nikah, or unpermanent marriage, or temporary marriage to a determined term. The debate on the permissibility of mutah marriages has spanned through centuries. A misyar marriage is a unique sunni muslim innovation. Jun 09, 20 from the website management narrations about muth in sahih al bukhari narrations about muth in sahih muslim article by dr. When it comes to the practical laws of islam or what is known as ahkaam alkhamsah in arabic terminology, we must say that every act that a dutybound mukallaf does is either wajib obligatory, haram prohibited, mustahab recommended makrooh abominable or mubah allowable.
Muhammad ibn yaqub alkulayni title subject download usool e kafi volume i hadith download usool e kafi volume i. There came to us the proclaimer of allahs messenger may peace be upon him and said. Mutah in sunni hadith proof that omar banned mutah shia. Also you can see the prophet saying mutah is haram in other hadiths such as this in buhkary, these 2 hadiths one in muslim and another one here, and last hadith in abu dawud. The shia fiqh of mutah mutah is arabic word which means enjoyment or pleasure. I newly heard thy mutah is allowed in iran and i was shocked. Mutah discussed, comments by salman sunniforum and. However, they disagree as to the reasons it was permitted. Flowing out of blood of a slaughtered animal in a normal quantity. Tauzih ul masail is an amazing app that contains a book named tauzeeh al masail with urdu translation. From the website management narrations about muth in sahih al bukhari narrations about muth in sahih muslim article by dr. The shii view in the sura entitled women, after listing those women to whom marriage is forbidden, the quran states as follows.
Muta ki haqeeqat pdf urdu book free download kutubistan. Here you will find a gradually growing list of articles, books, selected chapters, and personal accounts, on the issues of mutah, and relationships. May 22, 2006 shia today just use mutah for their own pleasure even though they have wives with them. Islamic library shia islamic pdfs now in collaboration. Sunni muslim and with in shia islam zaidi shisias,ismaeli shias and dawoodi bobras do not practi. It is like the perpetual marriage, as can never be valid but only through a marriage contract. Shiah kay nikahe muta aur sunni kay nikahemisyar ki haqeeqat. Tauzeeh ul masail by ayatullah sistani for android free. It is sad that the shia elders use false rhetoric to demand that their followers reject logic and morality. There is no record of it in the whole of the kitab ul ershad when the book is full of sexual issues that were brought to imam ali as.
The following are shia hadith from the most important of the four shia books of hadith, alkafi. Dec, 2011 most shia of today have a hard time selfjustifying the concept of mutah. Once you have mutually agreed that entering a mutah contract is what you both want you need to discuss 1 the time period for which your mutah marriage will last, 2 the mahr 3 any other conditions you may want to add. Much of this discussion is whether the practice of mutah is halal according to islamic tenets.
As far as shia or sunni male is concerned, i dont think they find any difficulty by marrying with a sunni or shia girl, respectively. This is what islam says about nikah mutah temporary marriage. The following are a few examples of ahadith from shia texts that have survived over the centuries when so much has been doctored. Ghusl for touching a dead body the obligation to give ghusl. But there is a huge disagreement between sunnis and shia scholars on mutah marriages, as per sunni scholars mutah was permitted in prophet pbuhs era but later it declared prohibited. There a lot of hadith in shia books that say that imams forbade mutah. The basic fact is that even the word mutah is not mentioned in this verses which normally is labelled as the mutah verse by our books.
Sep 12, 2017 mutah is also called pleasure marriage and seems very attractive to those who believe in sexual pleasure. Sunnis, have six major authentic sihaa sitta hadith books and several others to their list which are secondary on level in their collection. Mar 30, 20 shia dont rely on sunni hadith books sahih bukhari, sahih muslim etc, shia have several reasons as to why sunni hadith books are rejected. Aug, 20 the practises of shia islam from quran and sunni books the purpose and aim of creating the human by s. Also you can see the prophet saying mutah is haram in other hadiths such as this in buhkary, these 2. In this article, soa quotes the opinion of ibn juraij, the sunni mekkan scholar, on the permissibility of the temporary marriage. The name of books are links to the books, so just click these, and you will be taken to the desired book. English, urdu and arabic, you will be able to read shia books of different islamic scholars and the ayatollahs, it will help you to understand the philosophy, ideology and principle of islam abdul kareem mushtaq allama mufti jafar hussain allama razi jaffar naqvi allama sayyid murtaza. A man cannot contract mutah with a married women, as is the case with a normal other rules along this line are stipulated in our books of fiqh, which will be discussed in the appendix.
The shia are mocking the ruling of allah and rasool pbuh. Is muta a makroohdisliked or haram prohibted in view of imam ahmad bin hanbal. Engineer muhammad ali mirza official channel 947,301 views 33. Shiavault holds a variety of shia islamic books for online reading and in ereader formats epubmobi to the benefit of muslims and nonmuslims. I think its just hadiths with words twisted do that some idiots could fulil their sexual needs. Taijani samavi it means the mut ah marirage nikah, or unpermanent marriage, or temporary marriage to a determined term. Islam stack exchange is a question and answer site for muslims, experts in islam, and those interested in learning more about islam. The rulings on mutah have been different in different regions.
The companions that believed in mutah february 19, 2015 fiqh 7 after establishing in the original article that it is forbidden to practice mutah and that the prohibition was related by several companions, we will move on to studying the opinions of other companions, for our opponents argue that a large portion of the companions. August 21, 2015 in mutah, shia sunni, sunni scholars tags. Disbeliever kafir sweat of an excrementeating animal. In fact if it was allowed then he would have asked of it when charges of rape and molestation were being made against men.
Dawah to shia books on diaf e sahaba and analysis of shia belief. Mutah is arabic word which means enjoyment or pleasure. However when discussing with shia men or women, all of them always get offended when asked how many times they have done it with other shia men or women. Just because proponents of mutah dismiss them does not mean that they are not worth considering as credible evidence against mutah. Mutah means to marry a lady for a prescribed period of time, and this is forbidden and haraam according to all the four madhabs. Sayyad fadhil milani, spiritual leader at the alkhoei centre in brent, northwest london, is widely regarded as the uks most senior shia islamic scholar and has written about the mut ah marriage. The official website of the office of his eminence alsayyid ali alhusseini alsistani. According to twelver shia jurisprudence, preconditions for mut ah are. To the typical sunni adherent, none was so rigid in adherence that umar ibn al khattab and his reign is. Conclusion the fact of the matter is that the ahlus sunnah considers mutah to be haram forbidden, and believes this prohibition to be from the prophet. And they did not refute any of my references given in this article, rather accepted it by admitting that. It is perplexing that the shia scholars of hadith would use terminology i.
Much of the debate revolves around whether a temporary marriage is moral or not. The normal trend is to dismiss these narrations which are never quoted in books that justify mutah. Free download or read online muta ki haqeeqat the reality. Thus, a sunni follower should not be caught offguard when the shia propagandists take hadith out of context, pretending it refers to mutah alnisa when it really refers to mutah alhajj. Similar rules that apply for nikah apply for mutah if certain types of women are haram for a man to contract nikah then the same rule applies with mutah. Mutah in sunni hadith proof that omar banned mutah. As im married to a shia girl, therefore, im eligible to answer it. If its allowed then what is the difference between me having a boyfriend or just doing the mutah thing. Today iran has the biggest prostitution market in the region and thousands and thousands of foreigners go to iran claim to be shia and take mutah marriages for a week. Nasibi website tried to respond to my article, titled.
1343 535 509 402 347 1152 1383 794 497 692 782 755 995 1222 76 572 1217 197 1272 1314 868 485 1436 1233 156 875 275 753 362 1469 837 1124 1023 981 1345 359